Saturday, June 10, 2023

Toddy’s Appetizers

All my friends who live in the Five Towns area have been telling me for years that Toddy’s bagels are the best. Having lived in Teaneck NJ for high school, I am of the strong opinion that Sammy’s bagels are the best bagels. I realized that I would have to go and try out Toddy’s myself in order to see what all the fuss is about.

Toddy’s Bagels

In the Five Towns there is no shortage of Bagel places, ranging in all different styles: doughy vs light, expensive vs cheap, small vs big, traditional vs trendy, etc. Toddy’s Bagels is a very expensive and traditional bagel shop with very small bagels. I was warned about this, but it didn’t deter me from wanting to understand the obsession, even though I’m usually a two-bagel guy, which at Toddy’s could come out to $6.00.

 Another preconceived notion I walked into the store with was that the employees at Toddy’s would be very rude. There is a book (written by Toddy’s owner Jay Todtman) all about the fact that Toddy’s employees don’t really value customer service whatsoever. I have skimmed through the book and read the many hilarious altercations that have taken place between Jay and his customers. While very entertaining, I worried that I was going to be the next story.

When you walk into the store it’s a very cute place, a couple small tables inside and two outside. You walk up to the counter and they have all the bagels in a display. Besides 2 rainbow bagels that were tucked away on the bottom, they sell very average bagel toppings and flavors. Often bagel places will try to add interesting flavors to bagels to catch the attention of customers. I could tell Toddy’s was not the type of place to play these games. I went to the counter to order a salt bagel with cream cheese and a toasted whole wheat everything bagel.

Toddy's Bagels

The man behind the counter was very sweet and didn’t cause any problems. I was worried that getting to the front of the line without yet knowing my order would cause a stir, but the employee who prepared my bagels waited very patiently for me to decide what I wanted. In less than 5 minutes my bagels were ready. I wished the man a nice day and he reciprocated, no funny business and not even a hint of negativity.

The bagels indeed were very small. The slice down the middle wasn’t very even either. The salt on my salt bagel was all on the bottom and nothing on the top (which some might say is my fault for ordering a salt bagel in the first place, but salt bagels are for some reason my favorite). The Bagel itself was excellent.

A perfect balance between doughy and light, heavy but not too heavy, great flavor and not too much cream cheese. The taste of a bagel can be a hard thing to really explain or compare to other bagels, but the bagel I ate from Toddys was a very delicious bagel. I would go as so far to say that their bagels are the best tasting bagels I have ever eaten.

I was a bit hungry afterwards, and the bagel itself had a couple minute issues. I would highly recommend Toddy’s Bagels if you are searching for a very delicious bagel that has captured the hearts of many.

address436 Central Avenue, Cedarhurst, New York 11516
telephone (516) 295-1999

Google Reviews

[wp-review-google-place-reviews place_id = “ChIJodiiPsBlwokRYSdSq7f4Nhg”]

Yelp Reviews

[wp-review-yelp-business-reviews id=”toddys-appetizers-cedarhurst” title=”Toddy’s Appetizers” review_num=”3″]

Leave your vote

0 Points
Yonah Kilimnick
Yonah Kilimnick
Hi everybody! My name is Yonah Chanan Kilimnick, and I was born and raised in Rochester, NY. In around 5th grade I came to the staunch realization that if I learned how to cook, I could eat whatever I wanted whenever I wanted. 5th grade coincidentally also became the time where I entered my chubby phase, and there is no coincidence there. Needless to say, I fell in love with cooking, with trying new and unusual flavors, experimenting with a myriad of cuisines, and of course going to as many different restaurants as possible. Being that I am an Observant Jew, I will only be reviewing Kosher Certified restaurants, which you can often find in large Jewish communities. Anyone who has ever eaten out with me knows that I can get a bit snobby when it comes to ordering the same thing more than once. I am a firm believer in always trying to expand your horizons and experience every different dish that the world has to offer. Of course, I have my favorite places, but the goal of my posts is to try to experience different things that your average Jewish diner would not necessarily try, as I do every time, I go out to eat.


The Top 10 Local Traditional Dishes of Philadelphia

While there are dozens of traditional dishes to be found around Philadelphia, these 10 local specialties have stood the...

6 unique benefits OF black grapes

Black grapes are small, sweet fruits - famous for their deep purple blue color that makes them look almost...

Breakfast around the world: How do people start their days in different places?

No matter where you travel, breakfast is an important meal of the day and so are the ways people...
- Advertisement -


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.